The upcoming Toy Story 5 will bring a touching blend of continuity and tribute with the announcement that veteran actor Ernie Hudson is stepping into the role of Combat Carl, a character previously voiced by the late Carl Weathers. Disney and Pixar’s decision not only preserves the presence of a beloved character but also pays homage to Weathers’ contribution to the franchise—and to film history.
Carrying the Torch: Ernie Hudson Joins the Toy Story Franchise
Best known for his role as Winston Zeddemore in the Ghostbusters franchise, Ernie Hudson is no stranger to iconic roles or beloved cinematic universes. His rich, commanding voice and screen presence have made him a favorite across generations. In Toy Story 5, Hudson will voice Combat Carl, the rugged action figure first introduced in the original Toy Story and more prominently featured in the 2019 Disney+ short Toy Story of Terror!.
Taking over the role is no small task. Carl Weathers, who passed away in February 2024 at the age of 76, brought humor, heart, and a touch of self-parody to the role, creating a fan-favorite character in the process. Hudson’s involvement ensures that Combat Carl will live on in a way that honors Weathers’ unique performance, while also bringing a new layer of warmth and grit to the character.
A Legacy to Uphold: Remembering Carl Weathers
Carl Weathers left an enduring mark on pop culture with iconic roles such as Apollo Creed in the Rocky franchise and Greef Karga in The Mandalorian. His turn as Combat Carl added to his legacy of strong, memorable characters. Voicing an animated action figure gave Weathers the chance to riff on his action-hero image with humor and heart—a performance that struck a chord with both kids and adults.
Pixar’s decision to include Combat Carl in Toy Story 5 is a testament to the character’s appeal and to Weathers’ unforgettable contribution. The character’s scenes often stood out for their mix of parody and sincerity, and his presence in the franchise became something of a cult favorite among fans.
Combat Carl: A Fan-Favorite with a Comedic Edge
Originally appearing in Toy Story (1995) as a casualty of Sid’s toy-destructive tendencies, Combat Carl was reimagined and given a voice in the Toy Story of Terror! special. That short elevated him from a background reference to a fully fleshed-out character—gritty, intense, and oddly motivational.
Carl Weathers’ delivery of third-person lines like “Combat Carl never gives up” became instant classics. It was a loving nod to 1980s action heroes, voiced by one of the era’s biggest stars. The character balanced toughness with an unexpected sense of vulnerability, helping Combat Carl become more than just a parody—he became a vital part of the Toy Story universe.
With Hudson stepping in, audiences can expect a similar level of charm and humor. Hudson’s past performances have shown his ability to handle both action and emotion, often blending the two seamlessly. It’s a fitting match for a character who exists both as an homage and a fully realized personality in his own right.
Honoring the Past While Moving Forward
The choice of Hudson reflects Pixar’s ongoing commitment to honoring the actors who have made Toy Story one of the most enduring animated franchises of all time. As the fifth installment in the series approaches, bringing back beloved characters—while respectfully acknowledging the contributions of those no longer with us—has become a central part of the production’s narrative both on and off screen.
By casting someone of Hudson’s stature and experience, Pixar avoids the common pitfalls of recasting iconic characters. Instead, they offer a natural progression, allowing Combat Carl to evolve while staying true to the foundations that Weathers laid. For fans, it’s a respectful continuation rather than a reboot.
Hudson and Weathers: Icons from the Same Era
There’s a poetic symmetry in Ernie Hudson stepping into a role originated by Carl Weathers. Both actors rose to prominence in the 1980s, often playing military, law enforcement, or action-hero roles. They brought gravitas to characters that might otherwise have been one-dimensional, infusing them with heart, depth, and humor.
They also share a reputation for being fan favorites across conventions and public appearances, always approachable and gracious with the audiences who love their work. Hudson’s involvement in Toy Story 5 isn’t just a casting decision—it’s a passing of the torch from one respected actor to another.
Looking Ahead to Toy Story 5
Details about Toy Story 5 remain mostly under wraps, but it’s expected to feature both returning characters like Woody and Buzz, and an expanded look at newer favorites introduced in the fourth film. The inclusion of Combat Carl points to a continuation of the franchise’s tradition of blending humor, nostalgia, and character-driven storytelling.
With Hudson on board, fans can look forward to hearing Combat Carl’s unmistakable bravado once again. His presence will undoubtedly be a source of both laughter and warmth, and a subtle tribute to the actor who first gave him voice.
